This proposal did not pass. Share it with your community and try again.
Critical Minerals Domestic Supply Chain Act
This legislation streamlines permitting for domestic mining of critical minerals (lithium, cobalt, rare earths), provides tax incentives for domestic processing facilities, and establishes a strategic reserve for minerals essential to clean energy technology and defense applications.
Discussion (10)
This needs a sunset clause. Pass it as a 5-year pilot and evaluate results before making it permanent.
This is long overdue. Other countries have had similar policies for years and the results speak for themselves.
I propose adding a phased implementation schedule to make this more practical.
Add phased implementation timeline
+ Proposed Text
Section 3 amended: "Implementation in three phases over 36 months — Phase 1: entities over 500 employees; Phase 2: 100-500; Phase 3: all remaining."
As someone who works in this area, the problems described here are real. This would make a meaningful difference.
I propose adding explicit protections to prevent misuse beyond the original intent.
Add explicit scope limitations
+ Proposed Text
New Section 9: "Nothing herein authorizes action beyond enumerated purposes. Implementing regulations require notice-and-comment rulemaking."
Concerned about unintended consequences. Has anyone modeled what happens if this interacts badly with existing law?
The enforcement mechanism needs to be stronger. Without teeth, this becomes another unfunded mandate.
The timeline is too aggressive. I propose extending implementation by 2 years.
Extend implementation timeline by 2 years
+ Proposed Text
Section 2(c) amended: "Compliance deadline extended from 24 to 48 months, with interim milestones at 12, 24, and 36 months."
Good first draft. We need to hear from more stakeholders before finalizing.
Has anyone estimated the actual cost? I want to support it but we need concrete numbers.